当前位置: 华文天下 > 军事

印度人又造谣,称中国先进隐形无人机「攻击-11」就是一个笑话

2024-07-06军事

China’s Advanced Stealth Drone GJ-11 Is a Joke, Easily Tracked by Indias Su-30MKI

中国先进隐形无人机「攻击-11」就是一个笑话,印度苏- 30MKI可轻松跟踪

Facing skepticism about the GJ-11's stealth capabilities, some Chinese media platforms argue that simply adopting a flying wing layout is sufficient for stealth, and with the addition of stealth coatings, the performance is even better. If this were true, China’s stealth bombers should have already been deployed, but they remain unseen. This clearly indicates that China’s stealth coatings are far from effective.

During the Sino-Indian border dispute, two J-20 fighter jets, which are claimed to have stealth capabilities, were flying near the China-India border. However, they were easily tracked by India's Su-30MKI, showing that the stealth coating was hardly effective.

面对民众对「攻击-11」隐身能力的质疑,一些中国媒体平台认为,仅仅采用飞翼设计就足以实现隐形,加上隐身涂层,性能甚至更好。如果这是真的,中国的隐形轰炸机应该已经部署了,但仍然没亮相。这清楚地表明,中国的隐身涂层远远不够有效。

在中印边界争端期间,两架据称具有隐身能力的歼-20战斗机在中印边界附近飞行。然而,他们很容易就被印度的苏- 30MKI跟踪到了,这表明隐形涂层几乎没有效果。

以下是外国网友的评论:

yummm8775

It's not a joke. China's radar can't see it. But ALL other countries can.

这不是开玩笑。中国的雷达看不到它,而其他所有国家的雷达都可以看到。

breakwhiskey2863

You misunderstood chinese drones. It is only stealth when it is on the ground and not moving.

你们误解了中国无人机。只有当它在地面上不动的时候,才是隐形的。

RealJeep

I seriously asked a USAF pilot I know if China's air force was close in capability to the USA's. He just laughed, that's all I got from him.

我认真问过一名美国空军飞行员,中国空军的能力是否接近美国空军,他只是笑而不语。

kw8vw

Having done business in China I know that the only way that they can make quality anything is with American or European engineers on site.

在中国做过生意之后,我知道他们能做出高质量产品的唯一方法就是让美国或欧洲工程师在现场。

stuart3712

Not only did they copy the drone, they also copied the star and tripe from US military....

他们不仅抄袭了无人机,还抄袭了美军战机

Sierra-208

Heh, they tried to copy the USN's X-47, probably doesn't even have half the capabilities it claims to have

他们复制美国海军的X-47,可能甚至没有达到它声称的一半的能力

anijon

One should not be surprised if there is actually a pilot in those drones.

如果这些无人机上有飞行员,人们也不会感到惊讶。

jjgtube

Made in china say's everything about this product.

这款产品的一切都是中国制造。

PSeaFresh

China wants to copy an apple and they ended up making tomatoes

中国制造说明了一切。

cgdavid6017

I heard of a good rule of thumb when it comes to US military technology. Everything that we publicly know of in regards to military tech is 20 years behind what actually exsts.

我听说过一条关于美国军事技术的经验法则。其实美国军事技术比实际要落后20年。

jstring

I think they confused stealth shaped with actual stealth capabilities.

我认为他们混淆了外形隐形和实际隐形能力。

aata-zehad

Exsting Su30MKI is just 3rd gen fighter, that tells where chinese military capabilities stands. Only now Bharat started upgrading SU30MKIs to 4th gen capabilities.

现有的苏-30MKI只是第三代战斗机而已,这说明了中国的军事能力不行。直到现在,印度才开始将苏-30MKI升级到第四代功能。

caithyagyu3066

A kid said to his mommy" mommy mommy tofu" pointing at sky.the mom replied sweetheart that's Chinese jet

一个小孩指着天空对他的妈妈说:「妈妈,妈妈,豆腐」。妈妈回答说:「宝贝,那是中国飞机。」

jmshwood2801

Those who were impressed with China's technology ever since and even trashing their own countries need a good education on the realities of what is China is all about.

那些觉得中国的技术很强,甚至诋毁自己国家的人需要好好接受教育,了解中国的现实。

johnwilliams8855

If they are so superior at everything,as they are constantly claiming. Why are they so dependent on US and other countries technology to match or produce superior products?

如果他们在所有方面都很优秀,就像他们一直声称的那样。为什么他们如此依赖美国和其他国家的技术生产优质产品?

jiraiya86

Its definitely stealth when tracked by chinese radars

在中国雷达面前,它绝对是隐形的

bunnyfufu9933

I have never seen a fighter jet take off a chinese aircraft carrier with any ammo or bombs, not to mention i never seen them land on their carrier before

我从未见过一架战斗机带着弹药或炸弹从中国航母上起飞,更没有见过他们在航母上降落

apaitiadrivationo5628

They use chat BGT to design their drone

他们用chatGPT设计无人机

user-vpdi2gl9b

「Comrade, look! It’s so stealthy it’s disappeared from our radars.」 Meanwhile, some poor rural farmer, 「Oh hell. How am I gonna get that piece of crap out of my field!!??」

「同志,你看,多隐形,从我们的雷达上消失了。」与此同时,一些贫穷的农民,「见鬼,怎么才能把那坨垃圾从我的地里赶出去?」

ianfarquharson3772

They have to use drones because their young air force know how to use game controlers,but can't learn to fly an actual plane

他们不得不使用无人机,他们年轻的空军知道如何使用游戏控制器,但学不会驾驶真正的飞机

Doug-rv3nr

For those curious about the claim by India, there are more than one type of radar, long wave and short wave are the two categories that the other types of radar fall under. Long wave can quite easily track just about anything, even f-22. However, short wave is REQUIRED for AA targeting. India was able to target, track, and fire a simulated AA missile at the Chinese MRA. They even published a paper on it that is publicly available, though it's written in local language. So this isn't just a random claim, it is backed up by research and publication.

想告诉那些对印度的说法感到好奇的人,雷达的类型不止一种,长波和短波是不同类型的两种雷达。长波可以很容易地跟踪任何东西,甚至是F-22。

但是,防空瞄准需要短波。印度能够瞄准、跟踪并向中国MRA发射模拟防空导弹。

他们甚至发表了一篇公开的论文,尽管是用当地语言写的。

这不是随随便便说的,它是有研究和出版物支持的。

TaintedStaff

Wow the made in China quality carries even over to their military...

哇,中国制造的质量甚至影响到了他们的军队…

TheTektronik

Oh look, a B2 knockoff.

看,B2的山寨版。

stevenperry9762

Knock-off stealth won't cut it.

仿冒的隐形产品,不管用的。

Niskirin

"If this was true, china's stealth bombers should already have been deployed, but they remain unseen."

China so stronk nobody can see their planes, not even on the ground.

「如果这是真的,中国的隐形轰炸机应该已经部署了,但仍然没有看到它们。」

中国太强大了,没人能看到他们的飞机,甚至在地面上也看不到。

hungo7720

Chinese jets might seem ostensibly formidable but they are in fact, rudimentary compared to Western stealth jets.

中国战机表面上看起来很强大,但事实上,与西方隐形战机相比,它们是小儿科的。

keithcook3908

Looks like a copy

看起来像个复制品

CP-zi3eg

The only moment this drones were stealth, was before they were manufactured

这种无人机唯一隐身的时刻,是在它们被制造出来之前

SimonaDaRat

Just like with the su-57/75 , they are going to be extremely hard to find on the battlefield

就像苏-57/75一样,在战场上很难找到它们

MuhammedAjmalAp

It's actually extremely stealthy*

*Conditions apply To chinese radars only

实际上是非常隐形的

*前提是:使用中国雷达